"Drinking with Calvin and Luther" -Book Review

Drinking With Calvin and Luther!: A History of Alcohol in the Church

I got this book a week or so ago from Amazon and managed to breeze through it pretty quickly.  The author, Jim West, is a pastor in the Covenant Reformed Church and has a really good grasp of Reformation Era history and theology.  He is quite extensive in his quotes and stories from Calvin, Luther, and other Reformation theologians.  He also covers quite a bit of the Puritans views on alcohol and the early church in America, although he glosses over the early 20th century aspects that brought about prohibition.  That wasn't the primary focus of the book though, so that's not too big of a deal.

West handles the historical aspects of alcohol in the church well and does a decent job of incorporating the Bible.  He divides the book into 3 parts: history, theology, and a beer & wine guide.  Not too many books about Christianity and alcohol will provide a guide to help you make better tasting decisions!

The flow of the book is okay.  There are parts, especially in part one, where the author seems to jump from quote to quote and story to story with little transition.  I suppose it is difficult to weave all the different stories and quotes together well, but I feel it could have transitioned a little better.

My only real complaint about the book is that the author sometimes make an argument for alcohol biblically from silence.  The one that stood out to me was in regards to the Acts 2 accusation of Peter and the disciples being drunk and Peter responding that "it's 9 in the morning, we're not drunk."  The author takes this passage to imply that they would do their drinking later in the day, surely not at nine.  While I don't doubt the truth in that statement, we need to be careful about making conclusions from the Bible that aren't stated in the text.

Many of the other passages West deals with are handled quite well and there were quite a few great quotes from the book.  The one that stood out to me the most is in regards to Bible translation committees changing the translation of a Hebrew word for "strong drink" in Deuteronomy 14 so that it softens it for the Church.  West responds with the following: "The Moses Stout Text (Deut 14), then, is diluted and becomes a symbol not only of translation dishonesty, but of the watered-down message of much evangelical Christendom." (page 145).

Overall this was an enjoyable read, albeit choppy in parts, but the overall message is good: that God created all things on earth to be enjoyed to His glory.

Purchasing this book from the link at the top of the page or here helps support me!  Thanks!